Sunday, August 10, 2008

Tidbinbilla Eucalyptus cutters

TIDBINBILLA MEMORIES

On [a] still frosty dawn in July 1959 I sat on a log beside the old wood cutters' track at Tidbinbilla fumbling at the controls of a tape recorder with numbed fingers to record the unbelievable beauty of the Lyrebird chorus. Beside me Harry Frith said quietly "one day this will be a National Park."

We had left Canberra at 3am that morning stopping many times on the way along the unsealed road to scrape the frost from the windscreen of the unheated Landrover and open the many gates. We left the Landrover just beyond the eucalyptus cutters hut and walked the rest of the way. When we had finished the recording we boiled the billy and ate our breakfast as the two cutters went by with their old horse and cart to gather their daily crop of leaves.

On our way home we stopped to chat with Charlie West who was living in the farm house that is still in use in the Park. Later I got to know him well as he was my only contact besides the two cutters in the four winters I spent with the Tidbinbilla Lyrebirds.

For the first two years of the study I was in and out from Canberra but in 1962 we built a hut and I was able to place microphones all over the study area connected to a switchboard and tape recorders to track and record the birds and live in relative comfort.

In that time I often met Charlie and the two cutters. Charlie did a great job keeping shooters off the area and was a mine of information. I heard that he once put a bullet neatly between the feet of a trespasser saying "if there is any shooting to be done around here I'm the one that will be doing it." I do not know whether this is true but I never saw a shooter on the place while I was there. I was at his place one evening sitting by the fire with Charlie and his grandad and played one of my recordings. His grandad said "that's a pheasant, used to be worth two and six a tail but they aren't worth nothing now." The Lyrebird feathers were used at one time to adorn ladies' hats. We have come a long way with our ideas of conservation since then.

The two eucalyptus cutters were an interesting pair. One was from Poland and the other from Yugoslavia. They would work for three months cutting and distilling the leaves and then a contractor would come with a truck to take them and their drums of oil to Queanbeyan. They would return after a few days with food and a few cartons of beer. On these occasions I was always invited to visit them and I learned that their families were still in Europe and all their money was sent to help with food and education for their children, some of whom were at university. One day they came to me in great distress. There had been a terrible earthquake in Yugoslavia and there was no news of the family. I took them to Canberra and the Red Cross people got news that they were all right.

I finished the Lyrebird work in 1965 and went to Western Australia and when I returned on a visit to Canberra the Tidbinbilla National Park had been established as Harry Frith had foretold.

Norman Robinson
Sorrento, WA, June 1993

Saturday, August 9, 2008

4. Tidbinbilla studies

Significant references

Robinson, F.N. 1975. Vocal mimicry and the evolution of bird song. Emu 75:23-27.

Robinson, F.N. 1977. Environmental origins of the Menurae. Emu 77:167-168.

Robinson, F.N. 1991. Phatic communication in bird song. Emu 91:61-63.

Robinson, F.N., & H.S. Curtis. 1996. The Vocal Displays of the Lrebirds (Menuridae). Emu 96:258-275.

Robinson, F.N., & H.J. Frith. 1981. The Superb Lyrebird Menura novaehollandiae at Tidbinbilla, ACT. Emu 81: 145-157.

Friday, August 8, 2008

3. Tidbinbilla studies

Seeking song of chainsaws and coughs
Folk lore with Ian Warden

Out in a remote place in the Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve there is a sophisticated tape recorder in a box always listening (and being checked once a week) for the unmistakable calls of a bird famous for its perfect mimicry. The Superb Lyrebird imitates everything from the songs of other birds to chainsaws to factory whistles to the smokers' coughs of ornithologists that are watching it.

Peter Fullagar of Chifley, a retired CSIRO scientist, is one of three ornithological "detectives" looking for signs of lyrebirds at Tidbinbilla after the fires of January 18. Systematic research done in the 1960s and including lots of recordings of lyrebirds' calls found the valley especially blessed with them. In a normal June and July with the males going about their displays and courtships (they build mounds and give most of their virtuoso performances while standing on them) the valley would be alive with the sound of male lyrebirds yodelling their strange, zany calls in which up to 90 per cent of the emissions are mimicry, mostly of other birds. This winter, though, those sorts of places, of course badly burned, are eerily quiet.

"Normally at this time of the year," Mr Fullagar says, "and with a well established population you'll find mounds everywhere and beginning in June and in Tidbinbilla typically you'd find lyrebird song all day long. They'd sing from first light in the morning till last light at night. But there's not a trace of lyrebird song at the moment."

But there are some lyrebirds there, occasionally seen by rangers.

"Some lyrebirds may well be just simply working up and down various creeks just finding a living. Just surviving."

Mr Fullagar begins to feel sure that they're not going to hear any display and courtship calling this season because the lyrebirds are too preoccupied with sheer survival to have time for the busy foolishness of courtship and mating.

But this is what's making this season's investigations so crucial. In a project that could go on to last for 10 or more years this seasons deathly quiet beginning, a kind of clean slate, will help the measurement of how, nature permitting, the valley's lyrebirds slowly (lyrebirds are very long lived and they only lay one egg a year) rebuild their numbers.

One of the excitements of the project is going to be the discovery of whether or not the valley's re established lyrebirds change the contents of their calls. Of course they can only imitate what they hear of other birds and even of coughing ornithologists. The songs they used to make are in the archives, awaiting comparison with what calls are going to be made in the future.

"What will be the nature of the songs of the lyrebirds when they're re-stablished in the valley? Mr Fullagar wonders.

“Will it be exactly like it was before or will it be changed in some ways perhaps because the birds are not descendants of the original birds but have come in from [elsewhere] and have perhaps brought with them culturally the songs that they know [from somewhere else]? Or perhaps the calls will be structured around the redevelopment of the new acoustic environment of Tidbinbilla?"

For example, he explains, in all of the recordings so far done of the lyrebirds of the valley you never, ever hear them imitating the call of the whipbird even though lyrebirds that live within earshot of whipbirds leap at the chance of imitating that species' exciting whipcrack.

"And of course," Mr Fullagar enthuses (lyrebirds are so fascinating that even serious ornithologists become quite boyish when talking about them) "the reason for that was that whipbirds don't occur in the valley. When there are whipbirds around the lyrebirds will tell you that because they love doing whipbirds. And if they're not doing it in the valley it means that they [the lyrebirds] don't know about it. If they've been told about it they'll be sure to do it!"

In recent years studies have found the whipbirds edging closer and closer to the valley. Might it be one of the outcomes of the turmoil of the fires and part of the new acoustic environment that the lyrebirds will be able to add a loud whipcrack to their repertoires? The tape recorder in its box, all ears 24 hours a day seven days a week, will be listening for just that sort of thing.

The Canberra Times (page 6), Tuesday, July 22, 2003 [OCR text transcription July 22, 2003 by PJF using OmniPage LE and Adobe Photoshop]


Ornithological “detective” Peter Fullagar with lyrebird’s feather. Picture: LANNON HARLEY

Thursday, August 7, 2008

2. Tidbinbila studies

Published as: Davey,Fullagar & Slater 2005. Lyrebirds and Bushfire. Wingspan 15: 16-17.

LYREBIRDS AND BUSHFIRE

How did Superb Lyrebirds rise from the ashes of the devastating 2003 bushfires?

The devastating bushfire that culminated in loss of life and housing in Canberra on 18 January 2003 burnt two-thirds of the Australian Capital Territory and 88 per cent of the Territory’s reserve system. The fires were extensive and extremely hot, destroying both understorey and upper canopy. The intensive heat greatly affected the microfauna of the soil and destroyed the leaf litter, both elements critical to the re-establishment of the forest ecosystem and, in particular, the pace at which ground-feeding fauna can recover.
In the 1960s, Norman Robinson and Harry Frith studied the ground-feeding Superb Lyrebirds of Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve. Their intensive study, conducted two decades after the last major fire, in 1939, covered 37 ha, within which there were nine male territories. Since then the Reserve has become renowned for its Lyrebirds.
The fires of January 2003 were exceptionally hot and widespread. Amazingly, just two months after the inferno, in charred Namadgi National Park, close to 20 lyrebirds were observed. But, a visitor to the Brindabella Ranges three weeks after the fire found five dead lyrebirds. Interestingly, none had been burnt and must have died subsequent to the fire. Thus, it was clear that some birds had survived the fire but not its aftermath.
In the Tidbinbilla Valley virtually all food resources for Superb Lyrebirds appeared to have been destroyed. No significant areas of unburnt or lightly burnt refugia persisted anywhere near the Robinson and Frith study area. How had the Tidbinbilla Lyrebirds fared?
We decided to resurvey Robinson and Frith’s wider study area, of 60 ha, to see whether any Lyrebirds had survived and how they have been recovering in the years since. We combined three techniques: counting display mounds, observing lyrebirds on walking surveys, and recording vocalisations. Initially, the area was so devoid of vegetation that there was little possibility of lyrebirds not being detected. With increasing density of ground cover it was noticeable that lyrebirds would be visible as they checked out the source of disturbance and only then flee. But, by January 2005 the vegetation had become so dense that replay of lyrebird calls was used as an aid to locate birds.
Every three months starting October 2003 the study area was covered on foot to locate and count the number of display mounds and the number of individual lyrebirds present. We also set up an automatic listening station close to the centre of the intensive study area. A cassette recorder with an omnidirectional microphone sampled for c.10 seconds, day and night, at half-hourly intervals. The station collected data continuously from 1 August to 8 October 2003 and again for approximately one week a month from April to October 2004.


The automatic sound recording station used at Tidbinbilla. The lid of the waterproof box has been removed to show some of the contents, including the tape recorder and timing device. The two rechargeable 6-volt dry cell batteries used to power the system are housed under the false floor and the microphone is connected by a c. 5m insulated lead to one end of this box.

Our first access to the site was on 8 May 2003, 14 weeks after the fire. Epicormic growth was only modest by the time of this visit and ground cover non-existent. Treeferns clustered in the deepest gullies were beginning to sprout new fronds but the area was devastated and dusty.


The study area near the automatic recording station, at the site of the field hut used by Robinson and Frith in the 1960s: Taken on 8th May 2003, four months after the fire, showing the total loss of groundcover, understorey and canopy, with some slight regrowth beginning; Photo by Peter Fullagar



Two views of the same area. The upper picture taken May 2003 and the lower in January 2005.

An observation of footprints and scratchings of a single lyrebird on the 29 July was the first indication of the presence of lyrebirds within the study site. The first call was detected by automatic sound recording station 9 September; 40 days after the beginning of continuous sound sampling. From the end of September until 8 October 2003 calls were detected daily, and again frequently throughout the recording period April to October 2004 (see graph).


Relative frequency of Superb Lyrebird calls recorded at a listening station at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve. For ease of comparison, the blue columns represent the same months surveyed in 2003 and again in 2004. Vertical scale represents 'calls per hundred daytime samples'

During the first five-hour walking survey in October 2003 three lyrebirds were encountered. All were found where soil had accumulated, creating flat moist areas at creek junctions or at the head of a waterfall; places where tree ferns were regenerating fronds. At this time most of the creek beds were filled with eroded soil causing water to flow underground and these flat areas were the few spots where surface water was available. These locations appear to have formed the core areas for subsequent sightings (see map).


Locations of the accumulated sightings of Superb Lyrebirds between October 2003 and January 2005 within the Lyrebird study area (clouded area) at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve (creeklines are highlighted in blue).

Other birds
Like the Lyrebirds, most species have returned to the site but are in very low numbers. In two years since the fires 36 species were recorded and most species expected at the site were seen or heard, although in many cases only a few individuals were involved. However, no Pilotbirds or Spotted Quail-thrush were heard or seen although the latter species was found elsewhere in the reserve. Other ground-feeding birds were slow to reappear on the study site. The Wonga Pigeon was not heard or seen until April 2004 and has rarely been detected since then. Satin Bowerbirds were neither seen nor heard until September 2004.

The accumulation of species records for birds at the Tidbinbilla study site from May 2003 to January 2005*.


*Extracted either from field observations or from the identified calls detected in the sound samples collected at the automatic recording station: y = seen; * = tape recorded; (y) = tracks seen

Two years after the bushfire of January 2003 the number of Superb Lyrebirds within the Reserve is very low; few display mounds have been found and there has been no evidence of breeding. On the study site a maximum of three birds had been seen at any one time. By extrapolation from Robinson and Frith’s results, the same 60 ha would have supported about 15 male territories in the 1960s, and females and juveniles would have added to the tally.
Lyrebirds are sedentary by nature and the January 2003 wildfires were so widespread that it might be expected that recovery of the Lyrebird population would depend on those individuals that actually survived in an area. Colonization from outside the fire-affected area would require long distance immigration, which seems unlikely. How could even just a few Lyrebirds survive such an intense, all-destroying fire?
During our surveys Lyrebirds were seen disappearing down wombat burrows and Common Wombats certainly survived the fires—by May 2003 their distinctive faeces and scratchings were observed frequently. Hence, we believe that the most likely way that any Lyrebirds survived at the study site was by seeking safety within wombat burrows and other holes.

"When the fire descended, Mitchell [the surveyor-explorer of the mid 1800s] took refuge in the river and waited for it to pass. He was, however, not alone; because, from eight o'clock in the morning, three hours before the fire reached him, 'the lyrebirds began to flock from the higher country to take shelter in the river and, moreover, they could not be made to move from the positions taken up immediately on reaching the water'." L.H. Smith (1988)

Acknowledgements
We would like to thank Environment ACT for allowing us access to the area so soon after the fire and in particular Wildlife Research and Monitoring and staff from the Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve.

Further Reading
Fraser, I (2003) Burning and learning: the aftermath of the January 2003 fires in Namadgi and Tidbinbilla. Canberra Bird Notes 28: 10–16.

Robinson, FN & Frith, HJ
(1981) The superb lyrebird Menura novaehollandiae at Tidbinbilla (ACT). Emu 81: 145–57.

Smith, LH (1988) The Life of the Lyrebird. William Heinemann Australia: Melbourne.

Friday, August 1, 2008

1. Tidbinbilla studies

A long-term study on the effect of bushfires on Superb Lyrebirds

Some background details based on a submission to Environment ACT for permission to work on lyrebirds at Tidbinbilla


The avifauna of Australia includes many unique species. One of these, the Superb Lyrebird Menura novaehollandiae, has become an iconic species and no more so than at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve, ACT. Much of the pioneering research on the vocalizations and behaviour of the Superb Lyrebird was conducted in what is now the Nature Reserve at Tidbinbilla (Robinson & Frith 1981; Robinson and Curtis 1996; Higgins et al. 2001).

Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve has become well known for its Superb Lyrebirds. However, a catastrophic wildfire that occurred in the Brindabella Ranges west of Canberra in January 2003 burned a very large area including the whole of the Reserve. The effects of this devastating January 18th bushfires on the Tidbinbilla lyrebird population were therefore, and not unexpectedly, of considerable concern.

It seemed appropriate after the fire in 2003 to see what had happened to the lyrebirds of Tidbinbilla. Importantly, we were able to locate the exact area of creek system used during the earlier studies by Robinson & Frith (1981) and an investigation of this area in May 2003 was disturbing. It was clear that the intensive heat of the fires had greatly affected the microfauna of the soil and had completely destroyed the leaf litter, both elements critical to the rate of re-establishment of ground flora and consequently the continued survival of any ground-feeding avifauna. Superb Lyrebird abundance was therefore regarded, at that time, as a primary indication of habitat recovery within the Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve and an appropriate study began.

Populations of Superb Lyrebird are known to recover remarkably well following wildfires even of the most severe type (Smith 1988). Our superficial look over the study area near Mountain Creek in May 2003 confirmed, as expected, a complete lack of Lyrebird display mounds and no indications of any Lyrebird vocalizations despite this being the time of year when song output should normally be at its most intense. It was, however, only 4 months after the fire and it seemed reasonable to suppose that breeding would not occur during this first post-fire winter. However, signs of Lyrebirds feeding activity were found, although no birds were seen. We concluded that lyrebirds were certainly present but obviously in greatly reduced numbers and not singing.

In the years since 2003 our aim has been to obtain measures of Superb Lyrebird distribution and abundance over time in order to follow the recovery of the population in the Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve. Because of the widespread nature of the fire and the sedentary nature of lyrebirds it was expected that any population recovery would come from individuals that survived within the area or from nearby areas, but we really have no way to confirm this supposition.

A relative index of population numbers was initially obtained by measuring vocalisation frequency. Robinson & Frith (1981) had reported a mean territory size at this Tidbinbilla study site of 2.4 ha and a density of mounds of 17/ha (6-38) giving an average of 42 mounds for each territory (20-83). Counting active Lyrebird display mounds might therefore have provided a measure of distribution and relative density (Smith 1988, Higgins et al. 2001) but we concluded that it was too time consuming and impractical for our purposes once the shrub layer vegetation became dense across most of the area.

Transect counts of calling birds in mid winter and territory mapping of singing birds at the height of the breeding season song period have proved to be more effective ways to provide measures of distribution and numbers. Using these baseline data we have tried to assess, on a year to year basis, the distribution and status of Superb Lyrebirds at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve.

References

Higgins, P.J., J.M. Peter & W.K. Steele (Eds) 2001. Handbook of Australian, New Zealand and Antarctic Birds. Volume 5: Tyrant-flycatchers to chats. Oxford University Press: Melbourne.

Robinson, F.N., & H.S. Curtis 1996. The vocal displays of the lyrebirds (Menuridae) Emu 96: 258-275.

Robinson, F.N., & H.J. Frith 1981. The superb lyrebird Menura novaehollandiae in Tidbinbilla (ACT) Emu 81: 145-57.

Smith, L.H. 1988. The life of the lyrebird. William Heinemann, Australia: Melbourne.
A reminder. Aerial views before and immediately after the 2003 bushfire west of Canberra.
The study area is indicated by the arrow

Monday, June 23, 2008

5th Winter Survey

Superb Lyrebird survey at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve
22nd June 2008

The fifth annual survey of the Superb Lyrebird was again run under perfect conditions. Eighteen COG members met at the gates of the Reserve at 8.30am and were soon dispatched to the five main walking trails; Gibraltar Rocks, Devil’s Gap, Fishing Gap, Ashbrook Creek and Camel Back trails.

There were 19 individual Superb Lyrebirds reported which compares with the 6, 14, 12 and 12 reported in the four previous surveys. Of these, thirteen were reported from the Camel Back Trail with either 2 or 1 reported from the remaining four trails. It is interesting to note that from the 16 vegetation communities mapped for the Reserve the only trail that covers the E. fastigata and E. dalrympleana communities is the Camel Back Trail

During the survey 35 bird species were reported with the highest number (25) from the Gibraltar Rocks Trail. Interesting observations included Satin Bowerbird, Pilotbird, Crescent Honeyeater, New Holland Honeyeater, Eastern Yellow Robin, Grey Butcherbird and the very vocal White-eared Honeyeater.

Many thanks to the participants and to the staff at Tidbinbilla for once again allowing us early access into the Reserve.

Participants:

Margaret Strong
John Cummings
David McDonald
Paul Kirkbridge
Silvana Tridico
Martin Butterfield
Jennifer Engle
Paula Banks
Tina and John Bromhead
Muriel Edwards
John Brennan
Barbara Allan
Chris Davey
Peter Fullagar
Con Boekel

Sunday, June 24, 2007

4th Winter Survey

Superb Lyrebird survey at Tidbinbilla Nature Reserve
23rd June 2007

The fourth annual survey of the Superb Lyrebird was again run under perfect conditions. Twelve COG members met at the gates of the Reserve at 8.30am and were soon dispatched to the five main walking trails; Gibraltar Rocks, Devil’s Gap, Fishing Gap, Ashbrook Creek and Camel Back trails.

There were 12 individual lyrebirds reported which compares with the 6, 14, and 12 reported in the three previous surveys.

The survey is conducted at the end of June each year for it is this time of the year when calling males are the most easy to detect. A bird just off the Camel Back trail was in full voice and over a couple of minutes, in addition to its territorial call and associated whirrs and whistles, imitated the Crimson Rosella, Yellow-tailed Black-Cockatoo, Red Wattlebird, Grey Shrike-thrush, Pied Currawong, Satin Bowerbird and Laughing Kookaburra; all species commonly heard in the repertoire of the local lyrebird population.

During the survey 32 bird species were reported with the highest number (22) from the Gibraltar Rocks trail. Similar to last year there were more species on average reported from the three trails to the eastern side of the valley (18) than from the two trails on the western side (11.5) but interestingly, there were more species recorded per trail than last year when on average there were 12 species reported from the eastern trails and six species from the western trails.

Many thanks to the participants and to the staff at Tidbinbilla for allowing us early access into the Reserve.

Participants:

Matthew Frawley
David McDonald
Chris Davey
Josan Moss
Steve Holliday
Pru Buckley
John Waldron
Martin Butterfield
Vanessa Place
John Cummings
Anne I'ons
Sue Laskho